Tabloid Talk

Why signing this centre-back wouldn’t help our defensive problems at all

|
Image for Why signing this centre-back wouldn’t help our defensive problems at all

It has been widely reported that Arsenal are going to turn their attention to Scott Dann this weekend, and could table a £10 million bid for the Birmingham centre-back during the month.

You may recall that the 24-year-old Englishman suffered a major injury last season – a torn hamstring – and it is thought that Arsene Wenger wants to check that he has fully recovered before tabling a bid for him.

In my opinion, I do not understand why we are stopping our pursuits of Chris Samba, Gary Cahill and Phil Jagielka to sign Scott Dann, it just doesn’t make sense to me. I understand that the Brum defender maybe a bit cheaper, but the hierarchy at Arsenal have stated that we have money to spend this summer…so where is it???

In my opinion, Dann is a step down from every other player that we have been linked with and, in all honesty, I really do not see him as an ideal solution to resolve our defensive problems.

Don’t get me wrong, he is a good defender, but not an Arsenal one.

Ok, Dann has Premier League experience, but if we want to solve our defensive problems then we will need to do better than signing a Championship centre-back this summer.

Wenger needs to get his cheque book out and sign us a top quality centre-back, especially if we are to challenge for the Premier League title this season.

Wenger is set to send chief scout Steve Rowley to watch Birmingham’s first game against Derby this weekend to check on his fitness.

Do you agree with me?

Would the signing of Dann be a step back for Arsenal?

Give us your thoughts on your matter

Like what you read? Then follow me on Twitterhttp://twitter.com/UKVampire

Visit and Join our Facebook page, click HERE to do so.

Gunnersphere is currently looking for new writers to join the squad. Contact via twitter or at Gunnersphere@snack-media.com for further details.

Share this article

Writer For Gunnersphere

27 comments

  • Wenger can never learn from his woes and it is unfortunate that wenger now looks directly to cheaper and incompetent Dann. Whatever…

  • legoon says:

    SIck sick sick of looking to players that are 2nd rate
    REMind me wasn’t he part of a defense that got relegated I ssuppose that entitles him to go straight in our shit defense.
    I think the board needs overhauling big time or even shooting

    • SS says:

      @Legoon: Let me remind you…The number of goals conceded by Arsenal last season in EPL was 43. Blackburn conceded 59, Birmingham conceded 58, and Bolton conceded 56.

      By your logic we should look at neither Samba or Cahill. How would they improve our defense ?

      By the way were you part of the brigade who were shouting for Scott Parker….by the way West Ham also got relegated. I would rather put my faith on Wenger than you while choosing players. You could blame him for procastination but do not doubt his ability to find the right talent.

      I am not saying we do not need a defender. But let Wenger choose as he knows more about football than you. So if (as per you) Scott Dann is second rate, Samba and Cahill are same.

      • Paul says:

        Whatever knowledge wenger had has long gone to waste, he’s just spinning money from fools just like you.

        • SS says:

          @Paul – Your level of comments surely shows that you are not logical in your arguments. Otherwise you would tried to show some logic in negating my arguments.

          I also fully understand that descency is not your forte..otherwise you would not made comments like what you have made. Or you would not call others “fools” without knowing them at all….But anyway perhaps I was expecting a lot.

  • sam says:

    i can bet you that by january kyle bartley will be picked by england ahead of cahill and jagielka.
    some of you idiots need to start supporting man city.
    and you will be first to mourn that wenger doesn’t promote english players.
    this year he’s promoting 3, bartley, afobe, lansbury,if you count jenkinson it will be 4. still not good enough for you.

    • Pete says:

      hello, promoting players is not the same as saying they are good enough, wenger has promoted many players these last years and where are we? The club will never win anything with it’s currect crop of defensive players, never.

  • chris says:

    It matters not who Wenger buys in defence. We will struggle without a defensive coach – good enough and free enough to :

    > Organise the 1st team defence as a tight effective unit.

    > Train up young players to DEFEND WELL !

    Because we have lost all balance between attack and defence we have developed no good young defenders of our own … not one. Clichy was a good footballer – not a good defender. Djourou ? Senderos ? Gibbs ? They learn purist technique first, keeping the ball out of our net last.

  • nicky says:

    1. As Col says, Wenger sees in a player, skills of which the rest of us have no idea. That’s why he’s manager of Arsenal and we are not even on his staff.
    2. And listen to Chris’s wise words that no amount of defence spending will suffice without the vital addition of COACHING and COHESION that goes with it.

  • greenius says:

    dann?…..the issue really is what price will wenger offer?…..he wont meet the asking price of 10…he will offer 5 or 6….and hope that relagated birmingham will take it out of desperation. Expect a long drawn out negotiation with possibly a stalemate.
    No new players is my hunch.
    I agree with the comments that state we havent got a defensive coach…wenger is hopeless!….he wouldnt know how to organise a schoolboy defense.

  • vic says:

    wats al these abt scot dann being a part of relegatd bermingham team.dt doesnt mean he is nt gud. Afta al,terry,ferdinand,a.cole,caragher,barry n many odas were in d england team dt were disgraced out of d world cup yet they r world class defenders n far much beta dan d spanish defence.i wonda if most of us do watch futbal at al. Dann is far much beta dan 2 of d arsenal defenders put 2geda.he wil b gr8 4 arsenal period!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *